I'd really appreciate feedback on this matter so if you're one of those people who reads but never comments, I'd love to hear your story. As C and I aren't married, the concept of in-laws never came into play for me until I had a baby. It took a while for me to adjust to the fact that these two people, who lurked in the margins of my life, were permanently bound to my daughter. I'm still learning how to deal with them.
It started to respect them as Eliza's grandparents shortlly after Eliza turned one. Though I've always respected their need to see her and forge a relationship with her, I didn't like or respect them as people. Then I realized they weren't so bad and though I didn't exactly look forward to seeing them, I could enjoy them.
As C and I are trying to work things out, I agreed to go to his parents beach house for Easter weekend. This is a big tradition for C and his other two kids. Last year I managed to skip the festivities by deciding to spend Easter with my father. His parents haven't seen Eliza since December so I felt obligated to take her to them.
Unfortunately, on our first night, I argued with C's mother and I really have no desire to bring my daughter back to the beautiful beach house. It wasn't anything major, certainly not the sort that should make me feel like I do so that's why I'm looking for some opinions here.
C's mother is the social type who likes to make every family dinner into some kind of dinner party. The table must be set nicely, C's oldest daughter must take "drink orders" and trays of finger foods are passed around before the meal. Dinner usually occurs at an hour past Eliza's bedtime so I asked for an unbreakable bowl in case Eliza decided to hurl her food bowl off the high chair.
This prompted a big, rather nastily delivered speech on how there would be no throwing of food because she didn't want it on the floor or on the walls and how it took them 38 years to get their beautiful beach house and she believes in the word no and in her house I'll play by her rules. I calmly assured her I'd clean up any mess and that Eliza's a baby, discipline didn't really work until they were beyond 18 months and that most children throw bowls. She continued her dissertation on her beautiful beach house and her life and how upset she'd be if food went flying and I suggested she do what my aunt does. She replied she didn't care what my aunt does but when I broke in by saying "she puts a plastic bag under the chair," C's mom stormed out of the room to get a garbage bag.
Shocked by the ridiculousness of it all and angered by the venom in which it was delivered, I took Eliza upstairs. When I returned to find a plastic bag on the floor and a tupperware bowl of chili on the table I told C's mom I preferred to feed Eliza upstairs. She said this wasn't an option as she didn't want food upstairs and that they had the plastic bag ready and did I know how fond she was of me? I told her I was a little too shocked to talk to her about it right now, that this sort of conversation would never happen in my family and that I needed time to cool off. And that was the end of it, sort of.
The following day, she came down to see Eliza eating lunch and dropping hummus on the plastic bag. She didn't say anything and I thought perhaps my point was made and that things would be okay. However, later that day, when I wanted to serve Eliza a snack, his mother offered to help fix it. Her help in fixing it also included her walking up with a plate and spoon and forcing my daughter to take the cut-up avocado with a spoon.
Eliza hasn't been spoon fed for months. The only thing I'll still spoon feed her is yogurt and even that has become more of a challenge. She's starting to use utensils as she wants to do whatever she sees me doing. And I love it, I love her independence, her desire to get to the next level.
At first, as I sat Eliza on my lap, Eliza obediently took the spoon-feeding and part of me was angered by her lack of moxie. She started to reach for the spoon but C's mom pulled the spoon away, waited, then swirled it back towards her mouth. Quickly growing bored with this game, Eliza turned away from C's mom and reached for a bowl of grapes. Eliza doesn't even like grapes but I got the message; she'd rather eat something she doesn't like then be spoon fed. C's mom wouldn't give up, pushed the grapes away and kept cooing and offering her the shiny spoon. The look on his mother's face frightened me. I know I'm reading too much into this, but to me her face said, "you eat my way or you don't eat."
I also have to add that his parents refuse to do any kind of childproofing to their beautiful beach house. I don't expect every home we visit to be babyproofed but I really hate that they keep light bulbs, hammers and nails in the lowest drawers of the kitchen island. Eliza's a busy kid, she's a climber and the word "no" doesn't work like it used to. When C's mother realized that a quiet "no" wouldn't do the trick, she repeatedly got down in Eliza's face and said very firmly and very loudly, a little too much like yelling for me in fact, "NO!" C's 10-year-old son did a carbon copy of this behavior when Eliza went after the school project he'd left on the floor. I don't feel it's anyone's place to shout at my daughter and I'm not going to make a big deal about this but unless Eliza's about to stick her hand on a hot burner or hitting a kid, I don't want her yelled at.
So, how would you feel in my situation? C loves to go to the beautiful beach house and his way of dealing with his mother is smiling, nodding robotically and then doing whatever he wants when she's not around. I realize it's her right to set limits in her home but I also want respect for my style of parenting. A mess is fixable, usually nothing a mop and vacuum cleaner can't fix. But shouting at my daughter, even in the name of discipline, and forcing me to feel uncomfortable at every meal, this is something that hits me on an emotional level that will only get worse as Eliza gets bigger and so do her messes.
And C's mother is doing herself a great disservice. Eliza doesn't respond to her at all.
I'd love to hear from you all. Tell me what you think, tell me your in-law stories, whatever you think.